Showing posts with label doctor who. Show all posts
Showing posts with label doctor who. Show all posts

Friday, March 23, 2018

Classic Who Season 1 Review

Style: The quality of this season is fairly low and it’s entirely in black and white. The effects, when there are any, are almost laughable from a modern perspective, and the writing and dialogue is very 60s hammy - especially the death scenes, which are very unbelievable.

That said, if you give some permissions for the era, it’s not… terrible. It’s a bit slow and drags from a modern PoV, but I didn't find it completely un-stomach- able. And I hate watching anything made before the 1990s, so that should tell you enough.

Character: You have four main characters, the Doctor and his three companions - Susan, Barbara and Ian.


The Doctor - The First Doctor is very different from what we are used to see as a the building blocks of the Doctor’s personality, at least in New Who. He is a bit of a trickster and kind of a dick. He basically kidnaps Ian and Barbara in the beginning; lies for his own benefit; and within the first story, tries to finish off a cave man with a rock and Ian has to stop him. The Doctor is also kind of selfish and more interested in saving his skin and running away, than staying to help. In fact, even when he does stay, it’s always with the purpose to explore and the very real intention to run away at the first sign of trouble. He does become more… caring as the season progresses and in particular shows a great deal of caring to his companions, but he is definitely no Ten.

Susan Foreman - from what I can tell, Susan is the Doctor’s true, biological granddaughter and therefore Gallifreyan. She calls him “grandfather”; explains she is from a different world; later doctors make references to her and to the Doctor having a family at one point, and her description of Gallifrey is also echoed by later Doctors. How she came to be and whether she is a Time Lady or not is left up for debate, but there you go.

Susan is very much the child of the group. She is very young, only fifteen, and in several ways she acts like a typical teenage girl, especially one from the 60s. However, she is also smart and shows bravery and desire to grow up several times. Overall, I liked her a fair amount, in many ways I find her more easy to stomach than even Rose (although the fact that she has zero romantic interest in the Doctor - you know, with them being related and all - certainly helps.)

Ian Chesterton - Ian is a kind of a masculine ideal of the era, but not in a bad way. While he has leadership qualities, and wants to be heroic, he wants to do the physical work and he acts as the sort of the protector of the group, but he is also willing to step aside when needed, listen to other people and even let the women do some of the hard work. Overall, he was much better than what I was expecting and I can’t say I have many complaints within regards to his characterisation.

Barbara Wright - Barbara is a BAMF. She is consistently the character who gets the most shit done, is very smart, very clever, willing to stand up for herself and call out the Doctor on his shit. Not only that, but she is compassionate, a sort of a substitute mother to Susan, without smothering her, and just a very well rounded character. I’m confident in saying that she is most certainly one of the best companions in the entire history of the show. And once again, the fact that she has no romantic interest in the Doctor - or anyone else for that matter - certainly does help not to distract from her awesomeness. She has a few cute moments with Ian, but they are not over the top, and personally I think they'd make a cute couple,

In terms of the side characters, they were alright. No one terribly written, but also no one I was desperate to see more of. Honestly not much to say here.

Story - The plot of the season starts with two of Susan’s high school teachers - Ian, science/chemistry and Barbara, history/government - being concerned about her, because she is strangely smart and capable in many ways, but lacking knowledge or having strange ideas in other ways. Barbara in particular, is very suspicious, because there doesn’t seem to be anything on the address Susan gave. So she and Ian decide to follow her home, eventually stumbling upon the TARDIS and the first Doctor. Pushing their way inside, they find it all very strange and have a hard time believing it’s a spaceship travelling in time and space. The Doctor, deciding he can’t let them go, as they might give him away, kidnaps them. The rest of the season is spent with them going on several adventures, while trying to get back to their own time.

The stories are as follows:
The Unearthly Child:
 - Meeting Susan, then going back in the past to the cave men times (4 parts).
The Daleks 
 - The Doctor and his companions end up in Skaro, millions of years in the future, meeting the Daleks and the Thals (7 parts)
The Edge of Destruction 
 - an entirely TARDID-based story (2 parts)
Marco Polo 
 - The Doctor and his companions end up in the 13th century and meet Marco Polo (7 Parts). This only an audio, so I skipped it.
The Keys of Marinus
 - The Doctor and his companions end up in a strange planet and have to get five keys to the machine called Marinus, so they could go back to the TARDIS (6 parts
The Aztecs
 - The Doctor and his companions end up in the past amongst a civilization called the Aztecs, where Barbara is confused for a reincarnation of one of their goddesses (4 parts)
The Sensorites
 - The Doctor and his companions end up on a scape ship controlled by an alien race called the Sensorites, who turn out to be good-intentioned after all (6 parts)
and finally,
The Reign of Terror
 - The Doctor in his companions end up smack in the middle of the French revolution (6 parts, but episodes 3 and 4 are missing)

Amongst the separate stories, the action drags somewhat from a modern perspective, and most a are fairly long, between 4 to 7 parts, each part around 22-25 minutes. My personal favorite stories are probably The Sensorites, as it remind me most of a core Doctor Who adventure story, while trying to help an alien race (strange, as it’s rated the lowest of the season on IMDB). I really wanted to like The Daleks, but it was too unnecessarily long and tiresome, though there were definitely moments of it I enjoyed.

A strange thing I found is that The First Doctor says several times that “you can’t change history,” which is very much in contrast to New Who doctors claiming that “time can be rewritten just like that!’”, and also a bit strange as a concept, because what even is history? Any point in time is “history” to another point and don’t they change history by helping the Sensorites or finding the keys of Marines? Or is that just Earth history? Kind of a weird rule to have, really. But anyway, I’m very curious to see how the Doctor changes his mind about that.

Sunday, March 4, 2018

Doctor Who 1.08 - Father's Day

Overall opinion: This is another super solid episode to me. I love time travelling stories that deal with personal loss, even if we all know how it's going to end. The only complaint I probably have is that Rose's father wasn't really established before this point. I think if he had been, this story would have had much more impact. But honestly, it's pretty great as is. 10/10

The Doctor: I loved seeing the Doctor get mad at Rose, and then still try to protect her and her family, that was great, very Doctor-like.

Rose: I'm not sure how to feel about Rose here. On one hand, I relate to what she's feeling, but on the other hand, I hate that she insists on screwing things up. She is apologetic pretty fast though, so I guess that's a good thing.

Side characters: Oh man, this one episode really did make me feel for Rose's father. And that couple about to get married were pretty cute. Oh, and tiny Mickey! :D

Villain: There isn't one here, not really. There are these time-eating monsters, but they are not really what the episode is *about*.

Friday, March 2, 2018

Doctor Who 1.07 - The Long Game

Overall opinion: Um, this is a pretty good, tight episode. Good commentary, cool mystery, 9/10

The Doctor: Not much to say about The Doctor here, basically he is just being The Doctor.

Rose: Rose is fun in this episode, I like seeing the contrast between her and Adam, and yeah, that's really it. But it's good.

Side characters: Adam turns out to be a disappointment. That's pretty sad. But I liked the fact that they showed not everyone can handle travelling with the Doctor. Cathica and Suki are pretty great, no complaints about them.

Villain: Nothing much about the villain here, it's pretty generic, but I do like the plot they've come up with and I like the commentary they are making about television and modern culture.

Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Doctor Who 1.04. & 1.05 - Aliens of London and World War III

Overall opinion: Oh god, it's these episodes with the farting!

Okay, there are good ideas here and I get the commentary about politicians the show is trying to make, but my god, the farting! I think my biggest complaint about this story is that it's a two parter. It honestly does not deserve to be a two-parter.

In terms of rating: Aliens of London is a 5/10
And World War III is a 6/10

The Doctor: I feel like this two-parter is basically the quintessential The Doctor being The Doctor, he does have some really good moments here.

Rose: I don't know what to make of Rose here. She just stands by The Doctor's side, she doesn't really express a lot of deep emotions other than the obvious ones, and she's just kind of relegated to the background. The way people react to her is much more important than how she reacts to them.

Side characters: I like Jackie a lot more here, she is a lot less grating here because she acts very loving and concerned about Rose. I like Mickey a lot better too. I love his interactions with the Doctor, especially near the end. In fact both of them and their interactions with Rose are what makes this two-parter a little bit worth it for me.

Besides that, the alien doctor lady is cool, and of course Harriet Jones is a classic New Who character.

Villain: Look, I get the idea behind these villains on paper, and on paper I think it's an alright idea. But my god, with the farting! There's just no way to save that.

I'm not crazy about the design either. I like the faces, and the rest of them are just bleh. I guess I do like that the name they give is their family name, not the name of their species. And yeah, their plan is not the worst, but I still can't take them seriously,

Tuesday, February 27, 2018

Doctor Who 1.03 - The Unquiet Dead

Overall opinion: Another solid 9/10 episode. I don't generally love 18/19th century England in Doctor Who (though I think that has to do more with the Moffat era, where it gets way too overused), but there are solid episodes set in this time period and this was one of them. The supernatural aspect of it is a bit meh, because we know it's not actually supernatural, but the episode really picks up in the second half.

The Doctor: I liked the Doctor here, I liked his "new morality" and I liked how he is very much pro any living creatures, and believes that they are well-intentioned.

Rose: Not a great Rose episode in my opinion. This is the second time in a row she gets kidnapped and the Doctor has to save her (although not quite so literally this time.) And after, that she spends the episode being close-minded and a know-it-all.

Side characters: I love Charles Dickens obviously. It's a bit fan service-y every time Doctor Who brings in a historical figure, but it's still fun to see. He does take a little bit to come around to what's going on, but once he does, it's pretty awesome. Gwenyth is also one of my absolute favorite one time characters. Can't say much about her without spoiling the episode, so I'll just leave it at that.

Villain: I don't so much like the villains/monsters as characters in this episode, but I do like the interactions around them and I like the moral dilemma that they pose. So overall, yeah, it's pretty alright.

Monday, February 26, 2018

Doctor Who 1.06 - Dalek

Overall opinion: This is my favorite episode so far, by a mile. Everything about this episode worked, just everything. 10/10

The Doctor: For the first time we really get to see The Doctor and the way he deals with his grief and anger about the Time War, and it's great! It's so deep and emotional and he feels so much and the "you would make a good Dalek," line, oh man.

Rose: This is by far my favorite Rose episode so far too. Probably because she doesn't have too much screen time, and the time she has is well spent. She's empathetic and scared and then empathetic again. It's really good.

Side characters: Van Statten was a jerk, who got what he deserved. Adam is cute and I'm glad he'll be joining the Doctor and Rose next time.

Villain: Oh, man we get our first look at the Daleks in New Who and it's brilliant!

Like I said, when I first started watching the show I didn't know much about it, so  I had no idea what the Daleks even were. And as an introduction to them, this episode was perfect! So far I'd never feared or been creeped out by a DW villain, but man that this thing was relentless! And then when it realized it was changing, it was beautiful and poetic. I really feel like this episode genuinely conveys most everything you need to know about the Daleks.

Moral/Message: Not sure if this episode has a moral per se, but the message of it is very powerful and man, that ending. That was something, for sure.

Doctor Who 1.02 - The End of the World

Overall opinion: Okay,I love this episode! The pilot didn't quite do it for me, but this was the episode that sold me on the show. Not much else to say about it, really, it's just a very good tightly written episode. 9/10

The Doctor: Not much to say about The Doctor as well. I like that we get to find out more about his past and we see that the gravity of it all does hit him. I also think it's such a good establishing moment to see him at the end when he says "Everything has its time, and everything dies." It really says so much about him as a character.

Rose: I think I like Rose here a little bit more than the previous episode. I like that it hits her where she is, that she doesn't really know The Doctor very well, basically again the gravity of the situation. She is not particularly useful in this episode, but in fairness it's not due to a fault of her own. I really do like the conversations she has with The Doctor and with Cassandra. And I liked her empathy at the end.

Side characters: Okay, I like the blue alien plumber and the host and the wood people. Not much to say about them individually, they're just a nice addition to the episode.

Villain: Okay, this comes with a spoiler warning, so you'll have to copy the text in the brackets to see it. (I love Cassandra. I adore the commentary they were making with her, both in terms of racial purity and her greed, and the fact that she is judging the human race for evolving, while she has done much worse to herself. Her death was pretty gruesome, but also kind of earned? It was a good villain. Oh, and of course I loved that little hint they dropped that she is trans. Good stuff!)

Sunday, February 25, 2018

Doctor Who 1.01 - Rose

Overall opinion: Um, I don't think it's great. It's not terrible, but I remember back before I knew pretty much anything about Doctor Who, my friends convinced me to try watching it, because they thought I would like it.  And I remember just being so bored out of my mind during this episode that it took me several months to give the show another chance.

The special effects in this episode are pretty bad, the overall story is a bit of generic sci-fi with only a slight twist, the side characters are not the most compelling. It just feels a bit... meandering, in a way. I think it could have been written tighter. I gave it a 7/10 rating on IMDB, because I don't like being excessively negative, unless I absolutely hate something, but my actual rating is probably more like 6/10, or if I'm being generous 6.5/10.

The Doctor: The Doctor, is actually the one thing that was the saving grace of this episode. This will sound very shallow, but I remember being a little bit disappointed that the actor is not super cute when I first started watching the show. I don't think I knew about the regeneration at this point. But it was fine because he is established as quirky and interesting very fast. And also, Rose is more my type anyway. :P

The one thing I really liked in this episode, is the speech The Doctor gives Rose about how he can feel the Earth spinning, That was the one thing that really intrigued me about him. I remember the first time I watched it, being like, wait, who is this guy? And also, the TARDIS is pretty cool. In fact she is a saving grace for me throughout the series. Yes, she is a she, and she is alive.

Rose: I'm a bit torn on Rose. On one hand, I completely relate to her in terms being this young millennial who just feels so stuck in their life and who has no future and nothing that exciting awaiting for them. On the other hand, she seems a bit... generic. I can't really get a good sense of her personality from this episode. She does have a couple of funny lines, and overall it's not the worst companion introduction, but it's not really the best either. Although, I am trying to be lenient,  because it's also the show's pilot and it has to establish everything else too,

There's one thing in particular, I didn't really enjoy, and that was that whole bit with the ableism. I mean I can't really be too mad at it, because a) it's 2005; b) that's pretty much par-for sci-fi or fantasy that stars a "straight man" (to be clear, that does not mean a man who is heterosexual. but rather a character of any gender who hasn't been instilled of the true ways of the world, beyond what we all know, and that the audience is meant to identify with) and cat) that plot is resolved in literally the next scene. But still. Maybe it was a tad bit excessive, especially considering what she'd already seen at this point.

Rose's Mother and Mickey: I'm not a fan of either of them in this episode. Rose's mother is just annoying. Admittedly, that is by design, but it's still no less grating. Mickey is a tad better, but he is also sort of cowardly and just generally not very enticing. Which in fairness, is probably why Rose ends up leaving him to travel with The Doctor. I do like he is black and it's interracial relationship, but that's really the only positive thing I can say about him for now and that's really sad. Yes, I know he gets better. I do like him a lot more later on.

Villain: I think the Nestene Consciousness is an interesting idea, but it's just not explored very well. I like that the Doctor tries to talk to it first, rather than kill it. That really establishes that this is a different sort of show. And I also like that it doesn't go very well.

Moral: I'm not really sure, but did Rose end up killing the NC? Because it was implied that it was the only one, or the last one of its kind, so does that mean that The Doctor and Rose technically committed genocide? I mean, I get why, it was wreaking havoc on London and it was going to kill everyone else, but... I just think there are some moral implications here that are better explored in later Doctor Who episodes.